A beloved gathering place of the Whitefish Bay neighborhood, Fitzy’s Cafe is proud to reimagine the luncheonette and welcome you to our counter for wholesome food, great conversation and an unexpected taste experience right in the heart of the village. 

Craft Coffees and Drink Specialties

Fitzy’s signature beverage program offers finer craft coffees, seasonal blends and unexpected specialty drinks. You’ll find Midwest’s best artisanal roasters, along with quality ingredients like house-made bitters, syrups, fruits and herbs that form our trademark coffee and stirred drink recipes. Each beverage is blended with care by our skilled baristas and mixologists who aim to deliver expertly balanced flavors every time.

Our Food

When it comes to fresh food our eatery delivers. House made, locally sourced and organic foods are at the forefront of our chef curated, all-day menu. Made to order, our flavor-forward, seasonal menu highlights savory and sweet breakfast creations, French pastries and approachable bistro fare for the best in neighborhood dining. 

Sweets

Long known as the neighborhood pharmacy candy store, the cafe carries on the tradition and offers the best, locally-made premium ice creams and candies that are sure to satisfy.